Glede na to, da ni znana njegova DNK, tega ne moremo vedeti.
Domneva se, da je bil vsaj 1/4. Je pa to samo domneva.
In kakšna je judovska dnk?
Take sorte kot muslimanska, krščanska ali budistična?
Tole pa je hud znak nevednosti.
Hitler scheint genetisch mit Berbern und Juden verwandt gewesen zu sein
24. August 2010 Florian Rötzer
Der belgische Journalist Jean-Paul Mulders glaubt mit DNA-Analysen zeigen zu können, dass auch Hitler selbst kein "Arier" war
Adolf Hitler mit seinem Hass auf die Juden, seiner Angst vor der jüdischen Verschwörung und seiner Feier der überlegenen "arischen Rasse", wurzelnd auf einem verqueren darwinistischen "Kampf ums Dasein", könnte wohl selbst der Beweis für die abstrusen Gedanken der Nazi-Ideologie sein, der den Holocaust legetimieren sollte.
Der belgische Journalist Jean-Paul Mulders hatte für sein Buch "Auf der Suche nach Hitlers Sohn" (2009) Verwandte in Österreich und Großneffen in den Vereinigten Staaten ausfindig gemachte und sie um DNA-Proben gebeten bzw. diese über Spuren auf einer Zigarettenkippe oder einer Serviette heimlich besorgt. Er glaubt herausgefunden zu haben, wie die belgische Zeitschrift Knack berichtet, dass er genetisch mit Nordafrikanern und Juden verwandt gewesen zu sein scheint.
Mit der reinen Rasse war es also nichts bei Hitler selbst, wenn denn die Ergebnisse der DNA-Analysen der nur auf der väterlichen Linie vererbten E1b1b auf dem Y-Chromosom wirklich aussagekräftig sein sollten. Mulders hatte bei seinen Recherchen für sein Buch herausgefunden, dass die Haplogruppe der Verwandten Hitlers in Österreich mit der der Großneffen übereinstimmte, woraus sich der Schluss ziehen lässt, dass sie auch bei Hitler zu finden ist.
Die Haplogruppe E1b1b sei in Deutschland und Westeuropa wenig verbreitet, so Mulders. Bei 25 Prozent der Griechen und Sizilianern finde man sie, vor allem aber bei Nordafrikern (50-80 Prozent). Am häufigsten finde man sich bei Berbern und in Somalia, am zweithäufigsten bei aschkenasischen Juden auftritt. Ein Beweis hat Mulders damit natürlich nicht geliefert, sondern nur eine gewisse Wahrscheinlichkeit der Abstammungsverhältnisse.
Hitlers Sorge über seine eigene Herkunft, so Mulders, sei nicht unberechtigt gewesen, die Genanalysen hätten gezeigt, "dass er nicht 'rein' oder 'Arier' war". Mulders will nun von der russischen Regierung die Genehmigung erhalten, das im russischen Staatsarchiv erhaltene angebliche Schädelfragment Hitlers untersuchen zu dürfen, das letztes Jahr erstmals in einer Ausstellung gezeigt wurde. Hitlers Leiche war verbrannt worden, übrig geblieben sollen ein Kieferfragment und das erwähnte Schädelfragment sein. Ob es sich wirklich um Überreste Hitlers handelt, könnte Mulders mit seinen Befunden womöglich klären.
Govorilo se je, da naj bi bila daljna sorodnica, Seveda so to samo domneve.
Pa saj ona ni tako pomembna, razen da iste k istim vleče 😛
Bistveno je v tej temi, da ti trdiš, da Hitler ni bil Jud.
Kar sploh ne drži !
Najprej razčisti pojme okoli DNK in pripadnosti židovskemu narodu, namesto da mečeš vse v en koš z vero. Šele nato lahko gremo naprej.
Če si pozabila - tvoje vprašanje je bilo: In kakšna je judovska dnk?
Take sorte kot muslimanska, krščanska ali budistična?
Dobro veš, da DNK ni edini pogoj za imenovati se Jud. In da je v tej teroiji veliko morda in lahko bi.
Pa še vedno me zanima, v kakšnem sorodstvu je bila Eva Braun s Hitlerjem (razen da je bila njegova žena).
Ostani pri tvojem vprašanju glede DNK Judov, tvoje preusmerjanje tem, kadar nimaš odgovora nanje, je prozorno.
Govorilo se je, da naj bi bila daljna sorodnica, Seveda so to samo domneve.
Pa saj ona ni tako pomembna, razen da iste k istim vleče 😛
Bistveno je v tej temi, da ti trdiš, da Hitler ni bil Jud.
Kar sploh ne drži !
Ni res. Pravim da ni nobenega dokaza, da je Hitler bil Jud in da to da je imela Eva judovski DNK ne pomeni, da bi ga zaradi tega moral imeti tudi Hitler. Lahko mi pa dokažeš, da je bil Hitler v resnici Jud.
For someone so obsessed with “ethnic cleansing” and ancestry, Hitler was quite vague about his own descent. A lot of rumours have been doing the rounds that this was because Hitler might have been related to the very people he despised and persecuted, but none of them have been proven true beyond doubt. Hitler was definitely not a Jew in the true sense of word, but there is a faint possibility that one of his ancestors might have been Jewish.
Paternal Grandfather Theory
The identity of Hitler’s paternal grandfather is not known, because Hitler’s father has been registered as an illegitimate child. Hans Frank, a former Nazi official stated that Hitler’s grandmother used to work as a housekeeper for a Jewish family named Frankenberger, in Graz. He claimed that Alois, Hitler’s father, was the result of a sexual relationship with Leopold Frankenberger, the family’s 19-year old son. With further investigation, no records of the existence of a Leopold Frankenberger in Graz have been found, causing historians to dismiss this theory.
DNA Test Theory
The Daily Telegraph, a British paper reported in 2010 on a DNA study that was conducted on 39 known relatives of Hitler. Samples showed that these family members of the Fuhrer had a chromosome that is not commonly found in Western Europe. Apparently 18 to 20 percent of carriers of this chromosome (Haplogroup E1b1b1) are Ashkenazi Jews.
DNA tests of hair found on the hair brush Eva Braun (Hitler’s mistress) also pointed to the same chromosome, suggesting that she, too, may have had Jewish ancestry.
(from Daily Telegraph)
Hitler 'had Jewish and African roots', DNA tests show
Adolf Hitler is likely to have had Jewish and African roots, DNA tests have shown.
Adolf Hitler may have had Jewish and African roots, DNA tests have shown
Adolf Hitler may have had Jewish and African roots, DNA tests have shown
By Heidi Blake6:25AM BST 24 Aug 2010
Saliva samples taken from 39 relatives of the Nazi leader show he may have had biological links to the “subhuman” races that he tried to exterminate during the Holocaust.
Jean-Paul Mulders, a Belgian journalist, and Marc Vermeeren, a historian, tracked down the Fuhrer’s relatives, including an Austrian farmer who was his cousin, earlier this year.
A chromosome called Haplogroup E1b1b1 which showed up in their samples is rare in Western Europe and is most commonly found in the Berbers of Morocco, Algeria and Tunisia, as well as among Ashkenazi and Sephardic Jews.
"One can from this postulate that Hitler was related to people whom he despised," Mr Mulders wrote in the Belgian magazine, Knack.
Haplogroup E1b1b1, which accounts for approximately 18 to 20 per cent of Ashkenazi and 8.6 per cent to 30 per cent of Sephardic Y-chromosomes, appears to be one of the major founding lineages of the Jewish population.
Pa dokaži ti, da Hitler ni bil Jud. Saj si ti tista, ki dvomiš v to teorijo.
Was Hitler Jewish?
AskHON
For someone so obsessed with “ethnic cleansing” and ancestry, Hitler was quite vague about his own descent. A lot of rumours have been doing the rounds that this was because Hitler might have been related to the very people he despised and persecuted, but none of them have been proven true beyond doubt. Hitler was definitely not a Jew in the true sense of word, but there is a faint possibility that one of his ancestors might have been Jewish.
Paternal Grandfather Theory
The identity of Hitler’s paternal grandfather is not known, because Hitler’s father has been registered as an illegitimate child. Hans Frank, a former Nazi official stated that Hitler’s grandmother used to work as a housekeeper for a Jewish family named Frankenberger, in Graz. He claimed that Alois, Hitler’s father, was the result of a sexual relationship with Leopold Frankenberger, the family’s 19-year old son. With further investigation, no records of the existence of a Leopold Frankenberger in Graz have been found, causing historians to dismiss this theory.
DNA Test Theory
The Daily Telegraph, a British paper reported in 2010 on a DNA study that was conducted on 39 known relatives of Hitler. Samples showed that these family members of the Fuhrer had a chromosome that is not commonly found in Western Europe. Apparently 18 to 20 percent of carriers of this chromosome (Haplogroup E1b1b1) are Ashkenazi Jews.
DNA tests of hair found on the hair brush Eva Braun (Hitler’s mistress) also pointed to the same chromosome, suggesting that she, too, may have had Jewish ancestry.
(from Daily Telegraph)
Hitler 'had Jewish and African roots', DNA tests show
Adolf Hitler is likely to have had Jewish and African roots, DNA tests have shown.
Adolf Hitler may have had Jewish and African roots, DNA tests have shown
Adolf Hitler may have had Jewish and African roots, DNA tests have shown
By Heidi Blake6:25AM BST 24 Aug 2010
Saliva samples taken from 39 relatives of the Nazi leader show he may have had biological links to the “subhuman” races that he tried to exterminate during the Holocaust.
Jean-Paul Mulders, a Belgian journalist, and Marc Vermeeren, a historian, tracked down the Fuhrer’s relatives, including an Austrian farmer who was his cousin, earlier this year.
A chromosome called Haplogroup E1b1b1 which showed up in their samples is rare in Western Europe and is most commonly found in the Berbers of Morocco, Algeria and Tunisia, as well as among Ashkenazi and Sephardic Jews.
"One can from this postulate that Hitler was related to people whom he despised," Mr Mulders wrote in the Belgian magazine, Knack.
Haplogroup E1b1b1, which accounts for approximately 18 to 20 per cent of Ashkenazi and 8.6 per cent to 30 per cent of Sephardic Y-chromosomes, appears to be one of the major founding lineages of the Jewish population.
Pa dokaži ti, da Hitler ni bil Jud. Saj si ti tista, ki dvomiš v to teorijo.
emmmm 🙂
Pa ti veš, da s tem sama sebe zanikaš?
Ne. Priznam pa, da hitro in površno lepim, ker mi ta debata s teboj ni toliko pomembna. Glede na to, da rada brskaš po internetu, pa lahko sama veliko tega najdeš.
Torej, boš dokazala da Hitler ni bil Jud? In boš poskusila pojasniti tvoje neznanje o tem, da lahko z analizo DNK ugotoviš, ali ima nekdo judovske korenine? Dokler ne začneš konkretno odgovarjati na konkretna vprašanja, se mi s teboj ne ljubi ukvarjati.
Eni pa pravijo, da se holokavst ni zgodil in zdej še, da je bil žid...
Tiste, ki pravijo, da holokausta ni bilo, bi poslala v času nazaj v osebno izkušnjo.
To, da je bil judovskega porekla in da se je sramoval svojih korenin, pa je le še dodatni razlog za njegovo sovraštvo judov in ostalih "podras".
Eni pa pravijo, da se holokavst ni zgodil in zdej še, da je bil žid...
Holokavst se je zgodil, ne samo holokavst, ampak tudi pobijanje drugih narodov in ljudi.
Če Hitler je ali pa ni imel judovsko kri, pa sploh ni pomembno. Dejstvo je, da je v smrt poslal na milijone Judov.
Samo še črn ni bil ampak sigurno bodo "strokovnjaki" teorij zarote tudi to izbrskali, da je umrl šele v 70tih letih prejšnjega stoletja je tudi dokazano, no govori se potem mora že biti res 😛
Tudi v knjigi Spolno življenje diktatorjev piše, da je bil njegov dedek verjetno židovski Frankenberger. Babica Anne Marie Schiklgruber je delala pri tej bogati židovski družini.
Ime Hitler pa je Adolfov oče Alois prevzel po svojem očimu Georgu Heidlerju (ime se menda lahko izgovori na več načinov, tudi kot Hitler).
31.12.2017 ob 20:06